Vehicular Manslaughter in California - Penal Code 192(c) PC
When a death occurs due to drunk driving, reckless driving, speeding, gross negligence or a hit and run you may be charged with the crime of vehicular manslaughter. It is a form of manslaughter that involves the use of an automobile. In California this is a very serious legal offense and is considered either a misdemeanor or felony, depending on the circumstances involved.
If charged with a misdemeanor then you will be looking at up to 1 year in jail and if it is charged as a felony you could be facing an even longer term of up to ten years in a state prison. In addition, you will also face large fines, probation, driver's license suspension, driving school and community service.
When it comes to vehicular manslaughter in Los Angeles, there's a bunch of different levels of it. First, there's vehicular manslaughter where somebody dies and the person who was driving was drinking alcohol.
That's one of the worse vehicular manslaughter charges you can face and you can also be facing a second degree murder charge related to that. It really is a gray area as to what happens to somebody who is drinking and driving and kills somebody. Are they going to be charged with second degree murder? Are they going to be charged with vehicular manslaughter? Are they going to be charged with both? So, that's one area that the prosecutors are very serious about.
But I also see vehicular manslaughter cases being filed where there's no alcohol. Let's say a couple of people decide to race on the street. Somebody loses command of their car, kills an innocent person.
Both of those people are going to be charged with vehicular manslaughter because it's foreseeable if you're going to race on the street that you could end up killing somebody. So, that type of vehicular manslaughter is also very serious. It's a felony. You're looking at prison time and bunch of other ramifications.
Then, of course, if you just have a simple accident — you make a mistake, you do something stupid — they can charge some sort of vehicular manslaughter charge against you that is not as serious as a felony where somebody is racing and you're looking at a lot less time and obviously, a lot better result.
Another question that people ask when they come is and they're talking about vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated or even that of ordinary negligence which was what I was just talking about, is what do the prosecutors have to prove in order to prove that crime?
And in Los Angeles, they use the CALCRIM 591 Jury Instructions. 591 is a jury instruction dealing with vehicular manslaughter and it basically says that in order for the prosecutors to prove a defendant guilty of vehicular manslaughter, they're going to have to prove that the defendant drank some sort of alcohol or had some sort of drugs — believe it not, even drugs can be grounds for a vehicular manslaughter charge, or drugs and alcohol combined.
So, they're going to have to have that in their system. Their blood alcohol level for purposes of alcohol will have to be a .08 or greater.
The second element is they're going to have to indicate that while they were under the influence of that alcohol, drug or whatever it is or the combined influence of those, that the defendant also committed some sort of an unlawful act, and number three, the defendant committed the act and it has to be more than ordinary negligence, and obviously that a death resulted.
California Vehicular Manslaughter Involving Alcohol
So, they're really playing with the words here when you talk about vehicular manslaughter and alcohol. If your acts are very callous, wanton, you're running through red lights, going over 100 miles an hour and you've got alcohol in your system, you can bet your bottom dollar you're going to be charged with that most serious vehicular manslaughter and also possibly murder if somebody dies in the process of your driving.
If on the other hand, you just try to beat a light, you're not going more than the speed limit and somehow you get in a collision and somebody dies, that's ordinary negligence.
You're going to be in a much better position. You obviously don't want to be in a position where you're charged with a crime, but it's real questionable when somebody commits ordinary negligence and another person dies, whether they should even be charged with a crime.
I mean, that could be wrongful death — you were negligent, somebody died. You're going to be held responsible. The person can sue you civilly. But is it really fair that you also get criminal charges against you?
These are the arguments and battles that I have every day when I'm in the courtrooms in Los Angeles and obviously, I'm trying to do everything I possibly can to convince the prosecutors either to not file the charge, or if they do file the charge, to mitigate it down to something that's reasonable, that's fair under the circumstances.
So, if you've got a vehicular manslaughter case and need help, come to somebody who's been doing it twenty-five years and had a lot of success.
Protect Your Rights in Los Angeles County Courts
If charged with vehicular manslaughter, you will need a very strong defense. We will use our 75 years of combined knowledge and experience to aggressively defend your case. We are determined to succeed by obtaining a winning outcome for your case.
Call our office today to review the facts of your case, police report and obtain answers to any questions that you may have concerning the charges against you. You can expect a loyalty and trust that you can depend on to ensure your legal rights are well protected in the state of California.
How to Get the Best Result in a Vehicular Manslaughter Case?
Often, these vehicular manslaughter cases are just pure accidents, and the prosecutors shouldn't be filing them as criminal charges. It depends on the facts and circumstances of the case.
Of course, if somebody is driving recklessly or using alcohol or drugs and ends up getting in an accident and killing another person, that could justify a criminal filing.
But we need to look at the facts and circumstances surrounding what happened, whose fault the accident was, why the accident occurred, and what role, if any, the person's conduct played in the accident itself.
When we talk about getting the best result, many clients who come to me with these vehicular manslaughter cases don't have any criminal record. So if your driving record is clean, that puts you in a pretty good position to work out a reasonable resolution.
Review of Criminal Record
We have to sit down and find out what happened, number one. Number two, we've got to look at your history and see whether or not you've lived a good life and haven't had a bunch of criminal convictions.
Look at your driver's record and see how dangerous you are to the public because that's one of the biggest things that judges and prosecutors are looking at when trying to figure out how to deal with a vehicular manslaughter prosecutor.
So, of course, having 30 years of experience and having worked for the district attorney's office, and as a criminal defense attorney since the early 1990s, I have a pretty good perspective on when somebody deserves to go to prison.
Also, when somebody deserves to get probation and stay out of custody, that's one of the things we're going to talk about because I know nobody wants to go to jail. So we have to look at what happened, why it happened, and what we can do to mitigate it.
Meeting to Determine Defense Strategy
Sometimes we might even have a defense for the crime. That's another thing we're going to talk about in the first meeting:
- what happened,
- why it happened, and
- whether or not we could defend it and have you found not guilty in a jury trial.
If we can, then we will set things up. Maybe get an expert. That often happens in vehicular manslaughter cases to prove that the prosecutor's criminal theory of what happened is not valid.
If, on the other hand, they're going to be able to prove that you caused the death and it is a legitimate vehicular manslaughter case, then we're going to figure out how we can mitigate it. See if we can keep you out of jail and take every precaution to get you out of the criminal justice system as fast as possible.
Consult With Our Criminal Lawyers
If you have been accused of causing a death due to negligence or a violation of traffic safety laws, it would be in your best interest to hire a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer. In some case's a vehicular manslaughter charge can be upgraded to a murder charge.
At the Hedding Law Firm, we have defended many clients against a vehicular manslaughter charge with positive results. We also provide excellent murder and DUI defense representation in the state of California. Our firm strongly believes that you are innocent until proven guilty, and we will make every attempt to maintain your freedom and protect your individual rights. We can use an accident reconstruction expert in your defense.
In some instances an attorney at our firm may even be able to have your charges lowered or dismissed entirely. Does your charge involve alcohol? Contact our office to discuss all of the details of your case and how DUI charges may affect the circumstances of the arrest.
How Do Juries Decide Between Murder and Vehicular Manslaughter?