How Can Prosecutors Prove a Vehicular Manslaughter Case?
Under California Penal Code 192(c) PC, vehicular manslaughter charges can be filed against someone if they drive their vehicle negligently or unlawfully and then causes the death of another person.
Simply put, if somebody dies in a car accident in California, you might face vehicular manslaughter charges if you were driving negligently or doing something illegal.
The severity of the penalties will always depend on the level of negligence (ordinary or gross), whether you were driving under the influence, and your criminal history. Some common examples of PC 192(c) vehicular manslaughter cases include:
- A driver texting on their cell phone while driving and striking and killing a pedestrian who was crossing the street;
- A driver excessively speeding and driving recklessly causes a serious accident that kills the other driver or passenger.
In this article by our Los Angeles criminal defense attorneys, we will cover this topic in more detail below.
What is During the Commission of an Unlawful Act?
Under Penal Code 192(c), vehicular manslaughter can occur differently. For example, if you cause someone’s death while driving “in the commission of an unlawful act,” that is not a felony, but it is considered vehicular manslaughter with gross negligence.
Under California law, gross negligence is described as “the lack of care or an extreme departure from what a reasonably careful person would do in the same situation to prevent harm to oneself or others.”
Gross negligence is more severe than simple negligence but does not rise to the level of extreme recklessness. There is no complex legal definition that spells out when somebody acts grossly negligent, but California courts generally describe it as follows:
- significant negligence,
- an extreme departure from ordinary conduct, and
- failing to exercise the care that even a careless person would use.
For instance, if you are texting while driving and hitting and killing a pedestrian at an intersection, you could face vehicular manslaughter charges. If you kill somebody accidentally while committing a felony, you might face California Penal Code 187 PC murder charges.
What is Driving with Ordinary or Gross Negligence?
Under California law, a vehicle driver acts with ordinary negligence when they are:
- simply careless,
- inattentive, distracted, or
- commit an error in judgment.
Gross negligence, however, is conduct much more severe than ordinary negligence that is reckless enough that a reasonable person would expect a high risk of death or great bodily injury to occur.
If a driver engaged in felonious conduct, meaning conduct punishable as a felony, they likely engaged in grossly negligent conduct. If a driver engaged in conduct that might be a traffic infraction, such as speeding, they likely engaged in only ordinarily negligent conduct.
What are the Related Offenses for Penal Code 192(c)?
- Penal Code 191.5 PC – gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated,
- Penal Code 187 PC – DUI Watson murder,
- Vehicle Code 23152(a) VC – driving under the influence,
- Vehicle Code 23152(b) VC – driving with a BAC of .08 or greater,
- Vehicle Code 23152(f) VC – driving under the influence of drugs,
What Are the California Criminal Jury Instructions for Vehicular Manslaughter?
According to the jury instructions for vehicular manslaughter, CALCRIM 593, what do prosecutors have to prove to find someone guilty? Penal Code Section 192(c)(2) controls this crime.
However, you have to look at the Cal Crim Jury Instructions. Those are used in California and Los Angeles, and other counties surrounding LA. To prove if a defendant is guilty of vehicular manslaughter with ordinary negligence, the People must prove:
- that while driving a car, the defendant committed some misdemeanor or infraction that was unlawful and was committed with ordinary negligence;
- the misdemeanor or infraction or negligent act was dangerous to the life of humans under circumstances of its commission; and
- that the misdemeanor or infraction or negligent act caused the death.
This would be charged as a misdemeanor. This is where somebody is driving on the road, doing something stupid, and some other person gets killed.
For example, let’s say someone was in a crosswalk, and the driver didn’t see that person. They went through the crosswalk, hit the person, and killed them. That sounds like a good case for vehicular manslaughter.
Each of the elements above has to be proven. If the prosecutors can’t verify all three, they cannot prove that crime. If that’s the only crime the person is charged with – vehicular manslaughter – there would be a not guilty verdict, and the person walks.
Sometimes in complaints, the prosecutors charge more than one crime because they are trying to shoot a spray gun, so to speak, and see if they can get at least one of the convictions to stick so they can punish the individual involved.
Do All the Factors Have to Be Proven for a Penal Code 192(c) PC Conviction?
Yes. The jury instructions are essential in vehicular manslaughter cases because sometimes the prosecutors cannot prove each of the elements of the crime. For example, let’s say that element two, the defense, was trying to challenge and say whatever the person did was not dangerous to human life.
In our crosswalk example, let’s say the person didn’t see the individual in the crosswalk. It was late at night, and there was no light near the crosswalk, and it wasn’t prudent to cross there.
Sometimes the party who ends up getting killed can be the negligent one versus the individual who has the unfortunate circumstance of having killed somebody. That is compounded with the person being charged with a crime, which could affect them for the rest of their life.
So, suppose you or a loved one is charged with a misdemeanor of vehicular manslaughter or any vehicular manslaughter-related offense. In that case, you have to get somebody like me who’s been doing this for 30 years.
You need a defense lawyer who knows the jury instructions and knows how to fight these cases and knows when someone is guilty and should take a deal and when someone is innocent and should fight the case and try to win the case at a jury trial.
Pick up the phone. Make the call. Ask for a meeting with Ron Hedding. I stand at the ready to help you. The Hedding Law Firm is located in LA County, and we offer a free case evaluation by phone or the contact form.